I have been learning much from one of the commenters on this blog: James Williams, Author and Presenter on Autism. We have had a long exchange about how one particular social taboo has affected James and his friends, not only the Autistic Spectrum but also Neurotypicals. Due to the extremely negative social implications James has experienced when speaking of this taboo, James chose to email me the details rather than post it publicly on the blog. After our exchange, I requested James’ permission to publish his email, because I feel it is a vital example of not only our common struggle with one of the largest issues for humankind, but also a beautiful solution. The majority of our comments can be seen as comments to my post Social Football, however, the final comments I feel to be too important to have lost pages down, hidden in multiple exchanges, therefore, I have included here the ultimate exchange in its final form. I commend James on his self-conduct, in his life and in his comments. James is an honoring and respectful example of sociocultural evolution.
James’ email is in italics, my comments are in all caps:
Birdie,
In this e-mail I shall write the underlying issue that I have disguised for the purposes of censorship. In my opinion, it should be written this way, because the posts are purposely written to convey a general point built from a specific issue. THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO COMMENT ON THIS SUBJECT. I WOULD LIKE TO OFFER AN INTENTION OF PROVIDING MY PERSPECTIVE ON THIS, NOT AS ADVICE, BECAUSE I AM NOBODY TO GIVE ADVICE, BUT RATHER AS A DIFFERENT VIEWPOINT BECAUSE IT IS SOMETIMES DIFFICULT TO TAKE A STEP BACK FROM EXTREMELY VOLATILE EVENTS IN ONE’S LIFE AND SEE THE BIG PICTURE. I FIND THAT WHEN I CAN SEE A LARGER WORLD VIEW, THINGS IN MY LIFE THAT I MIGHT VIEW AS ISSUES CAN TURN INTO GIFTS.
In my two “Social Football” posts, I describe two aspects of my social life–one regarding how I ended up making friends with a group of gender rebels, and how their strong passionate beliefs enabled them to be very accepting of me, since I openly supported their gender rebellion. The other is about how my worldview was changed due to the struggles of my AS friends. Interestingly, both aspects of my social life, although belonging to two very different social circles, were linked together due to a core issue that was a major part of the social interactions of both my gender rebel friends and my AS friends. THE ISSUES SURROUNDING MENSTRUATION ARE LIKE A FESTERING INFECTION AFFECTING THE EARTH ON A GRAND LEVEL. FROM MY PERSPECTIVE YOUR SEEMINGLY COINCIDENTAL INVOLVEMENT IN IT IS MORE THAN COINCIDENCE. IT LOOKS LIKE A PERFECT STORM OF SKILL SET, SOCIAL PLACEMENT, OPPORTUNITY, AND SUPPORT.
What was the issue that linked us all together?
Menstruation. Also known as a girl’s “time of the month,” or a girl’s “period.” THE TV SHOW “2 BROKE GIRLS” HAD AN EPISODE WHERE ONE OF THE GIRLS WAS UPSET WITH THE TABOO OF MENSTRUATION AND WAS OPENLY THROWING THE ISSUE INTO THE FACES OF RESTAURANT PATRONS WHERE SHE WAITRESSED. I BELIEVE THIS SHOWS A READINESS AND A NECESSITY FOR THE KIND OF CHALLENGE THAT YOU AND YOUR FRIENDS ARE PRESENTING.
When I befriended the gender rebels, one of their strong beliefs was an opposition to society’s menstrual taboo. They believed that since all girls have to cope with menstruation, girls should have the right to speak freely about it with whoever they want to. They believed firmly that girls should be allowed to talk to boys about their periods if they wanted to, and that since menstruation is a uncomfortable thing for girls to cope with, girls should be allowed to speak about their menstrual problems with whoever they feel comfortable with, not who society tells them they should talk to. And there were some girls who voiced that they felt frustrated with rules telling them that they could only talk to other girls about their periods, since they often struggled with making friends with other girls due to the “cliquey” nature of many girls at my school.
This was one of the reasons why I was given such unconditional acceptance among the gender rebels. Since period talk does not make me uncomfortable, the female gender rebels valued the fact that they could talk to a guy about menstruation. And the male gender rebels valued me for this too since they saw an example of yet another male who was not bothered by such discussion, thus revealing that they were not entirely alone in the world. WHILE YOUR EXPERIENCE IS THAT YOUR MOTIVATION WAS FOR ACCEPTANCE, MY OBSERVATION IS THAT FOR MANY, ALL THE ACCEPTANCE IN THE WORLD WOULD NOT BE ENOUGH TO CAUSE THEM TO BE COMFORTABLE WITH IT THE WAY YOU ARE. IT TAKES AN ADVANCED CONSCIOUSNESS TO GRASP AND EMBODY THE PHILOSOPHY YOU HAVE ADOPTED ABOUT THIS UNCOMFORTABLE SUBJECT.
I have also pointed out in my posts that I have a small group of AS female friends. One common issue I hear routinely from my AS female friends is that they struggle to cope with menstruation. The “medical issue” that I described in my post that worsens my friends’ functioning and causes physical struggles, is menstruation. When many of my AS friends get their periods every month (or sometimes before, or just before and during), their symptoms with AS worsen and they lose a part of their functioning. At the same time, that functioning loss is often quite visible, yet due to society’s rules, they cannot openly reveal why they have lost their functioning. And then, when their period ends, they return back to their usual AS selves, only to have a loss of functioning next month. Some of my AS friends have actual physical ailments, and suffer from massive headaches, vomiting, and the inability to digest food during their periods. Another issue that emerges is the struggle with managing menstruation–I have traveled with two adult female friends with AS and both times I have traveled with them, I have had to assist them with their menstrual hygiene. Both knew how to use menstrual supplies but both needed to be reminded of when to change their supplies. And my close AS female friends come to me because they do not feel as if they can talk to other females about this issue, viewing them as being too judgmental to listen. NONJUDGMENT, WHAT A BEAUTIFUL CONCEPT, AND ONE NOT OFTEN FOUND IN HUMANS. THANK YOU!
Although the gender rebels and I spoke freely about this subject, they did so based on moral beliefs. But when my AS female friends and I get into this subject, we do so because my AS female friends often feel as if they do not have many other people they can talk to about their menstrual struggles. But the core belief of both–that society’s menstrual taboo is wrong–links together both parts of my social life. And I have met a few men with AS who value me for my willingness to listen to those AS females, since they too have female friends who struggle with the same thing and they listen to them as well. One AS male told me he was happy to know he wasn’t the only AS male he knew that comfortably listened to period problems. AGAIN, I SEE A MUCH MORE BEAUTIFUL INTERACTION TAKING PLACE HERE THAN A SIMPLE EXCHANGE OF PRODUCTS SUCH AS ACCEPTANCE AND CONVERSATION. IT APPEARS TO ME THAT YOU ALL ARE CREATING THE GROUNDWORK, THE FOUNDATION FOR FUTURE BENEFICIAL INTERACTIONS SURROUNDING A CORE HUMAN ISSUE, AN ISSUE THAT COVERS EVEN MORE THAN WHAT IS APPARENT ON ITS FACE. IT HAS VERY DEEP-RUNNING VEINS OF MALE/FEMALE INTERACTION IMBALANCES AND DISTRUST.
So there you have it. This is the issue that changed my worldview on things, and forever shattered my way of thinking. And this is the issue that my friends and I navigate together. And if you are offended, you may discontinue any social ties you have with me.I AM NOT ONLY NOT OFFENDED, I AM ENERGIZED AND GRATEFUL FOR YOUR INSIGHTS ABOUT THIS, BUT I THANK YOU FOR YOUR WILLINGNESS TO ADDRESS A SUBJECT WHICH COULD OFFEND ME. THAT TAKES GREAT, GREAT COURAGE IN THIS WORLD OF OURS. I UNDERSTAND YOUR CHOICES IN THIS REGARD HAVE PLACED YOU IN A POSITION TO RECEIVE NEGATIVE REACTIONS. SOME MIGHT VIEW THIS AS A SIGN THAT WHAT THEY ARE DOING IS “WRONG.” I SEE WHAT YOU ARE DOING AS AMAZING. – BIRDIE
James